News

BBC QT row explodes over state pension triple lock as panellist says scrap it!.uk

Question Time panellists called for a “national conversation” on the future of the triple lock amid a fiery debate on Labour’s winter fuel payment U-turn.

A split image of two ladies

The panellists argued that the future of the triple lock should be discussed (Image: BBC)

A Question Time panellist has called for the triple lock to be scrapped amid a fiery debate about the Government’s winter fuel payment U-turn. Responding to an audience question about whether or not the Prime Minister needs a roadmap following his latest change in direction, Brexit columnist Inaya Folarin Iman, agreed suggesting that the decision came following the local election results and the rise of Reform UK.

Ms Iman said: “The problem is that there are bigger questions that we need to ask as a society when it comes to an ageing population. Whether that’s the social care crisis or whether that’s the question of the triple lock on pensions. I am in my 20s and I speak to other people in their 20s who don’t believe that they will get a state pension.”

DON’T MISS
Powered by 
The battle to succeed Sir Keir Starmer has already started
The battle to succeed Sir Keir Starmer has already started

Comments

MPs condemn 'bizarre' state pension rule as 500,000 get no triple lock increase
MPs condemn ‘bizarre’ state pension rule as 500,000 get no triple lock increase
Kemi Badenoch slams 'desperate' Keir Starmer for 'shafting country' on winter fuel U-turn
Kemi Badenoch slams ‘desperate’ Keir Starmer for ‘shafting country’ on winter fuel U-turn

Comments

Keir Starmer's EU sellout perfectly skewered in seven-word slapdown of PM
Keir Starmer’s EU sellout perfectly skewered in seven-word slapdown of PM
Keir Starmer has no backbone and pensioners shoul be worried about his winter fuel U-turn
Keir Starmer has no backbone and pensioners shoul be worried about his winter fuel U-turn

Comments

Pensioners want clarity on Keir Starmer's 'screeching' winter fuel payment U-turn
Pensioners want clarity on Keir Starmer’s ‘screeching’ winter fuel payment U-turn
Keir Starmer's winter fuel 'panic' exposed as PM warned 'voters won't buy it'
Keir Starmer’s winter fuel ‘panic’ exposed as PM warned ‘voters won’t buy it’

Comments

Keir Starmer set for huge winter fuel u-turn in June after huge defeat
Keir Starmer set for huge winter fuel u-turn in June after huge defeat
Kemi Badenoch buries Keir Starmer as red-faced PM scrambles for insulting default reply
Kemi Badenoch buries Keir Starmer as red-faced PM scrambles for insulting default reply
I'm an expert - Rachel Reeves will have to give all pensioners winter fuel money back
I’m an expert – Rachel Reeves will have to give all pensioners winter fuel money back
Keir Starmer confirms huge winter fuel payment U-turn in bombshell PMQs clash
Keir Starmer confirms huge winter fuel payment U-turn in bombshell PMQs clash
'Were you lying?' GB News star skewers Labour minister in furious migrant row
‘Were you lying?’ GB News star skewers Labour minister in furious migrant row
Keir Starmer torn apart with just three words as GB News star unleashes fury at EU deal
Keir Starmer torn apart with just three words as GB News star unleashes fury at EU deal
Moment Labour minister refuses to rule out major winter fuel cut U-turn
Moment Labour minister refuses to rule out major winter fuel cut U-turn
Labour MP squirms as Fiona Bruce asks 7 times for straight answer on winter fuel u-turn
Labour MP squirms as Fiona Bruce asks 7 times for straight answer on winter fuel u-turn
Furious Labour MPs demand answers 'NOW' after winter fuel U-turn from Starmer
Furious Labour MPs demand answers ‘NOW’ after winter fuel U-turn from Starmer
Experts predict Keir Starmer's next move as 'mystery' of winter fuel U-turn remains
Experts predict Keir Starmer’s next move as ‘mystery’ of winter fuel U-turn remains
Martin Lewis pushes for Winter Fuel Payment to pensioners on these council tax bands
Martin Lewis pushes for Winter Fuel Payment to pensioners on these council tax bands
Kemi Badenoch vows to continue fight for pensioners after Keir Starmer's U-turn
Kemi Badenoch vows to continue fight for pensioners after Keir Starmer’s U-turn
Pensioners could be forced to wait 12 months for Keir Starmer's winter fuel U-turn
Pensioners could be forced to wait 12 months for Keir Starmer’s winter fuel U-turn
The battle to succeed Sir Keir Starmer has already started
The battle to succeed Sir Keir Starmer has already started
MPs condemn 'bizarre' state pension rule as 500,000 get no triple lock increase
MPs condemn ‘bizarre’ state pension rule as 500,000 get no triple lock increase
Kemi Badenoch slams 'desperate' Keir Starmer for 'shafting country' on winter fuel U-turn
Kemi Badenoch slams ‘desperate’ Keir Starmer for ‘shafting country’ on winter fuel U-turn
Keir Starmer's EU sellout perfectly skewered in seven-word slapdown of PM
Keir Starmer’s EU sellout perfectly skewered in seven-word slapdown of PM
Keir Starmer has no backbone and pensioners shoul be worried about his winter fuel U-turn
Keir Starmer has no backbone and pensioners shoul be worried about his winter fuel U-turn
Pensioners want clarity on Keir Starmer's 'screeching' winter fuel payment U-turn
Pensioners want clarity on Keir Starmer’s ‘screeching’ winter fuel payment U-turn
Keir Starmer's winter fuel 'panic' exposed as PM warned 'voters won't buy it'
Keir Starmer’s winter fuel ‘panic’ exposed as PM warned ‘voters won’t buy it’
Keir Starmer set for huge winter fuel u-turn in June after huge defeat
Keir Starmer set for huge winter fuel u-turn in June after huge defeat
Kemi Badenoch buries Keir Starmer as red-faced PM scrambles for insulting default reply
Kemi Badenoch buries Keir Starmer as red-faced PM scrambles for insulting default reply
I'm an expert - Rachel Reeves will have to give all pensioners winter fuel money back
I’m an expert – Rachel Reeves will have to give all pensioners winter fuel money back
Keir Starmer confirms huge winter fuel payment U-turn in bombshell PMQs clash
Keir Starmer confirms huge winter fuel payment U-turn in bombshell PMQs clash
'Were you lying?' GB News star skewers Labour minister in furious migrant row
‘Were you lying?’ GB News star skewers Labour minister in furious migrant row
Keir Starmer torn apart with just three words as GB News star unleashes fury at EU deal
Keir Starmer torn apart with just three words as GB News star unleashes fury at EU deal
Moment Labour minister refuses to rule out major winter fuel cut U-turn
Moment Labour minister refuses to rule out major winter fuel cut U-turn
Labour MP squirms as Fiona Bruce asks 7 times for straight answer on winter fuel u-turn
Labour MP squirms as Fiona Bruce asks 7 times for straight answer on winter fuel u-turn
Furious Labour MPs demand answers 'NOW' after winter fuel U-turn from Starmer
Furious Labour MPs demand answers ‘NOW’ after winter fuel U-turn from Starmer
Experts predict Keir Starmer's next move as 'mystery' of winter fuel U-turn remains
Experts predict Keir Starmer’s next move as ‘mystery’ of winter fuel U-turn remains
Martin Lewis pushes for Winter Fuel Payment to pensioners on these council tax bands
Martin Lewis pushes for Winter Fuel Payment to pensioners on these council tax bands
Kemi Badenoch vows to continue fight for pensioners after Keir Starmer's U-turn
Kemi Badenoch vows to continue fight for pensioners after Keir Starmer’s U-turn
Pensioners could be forced to wait 12 months for Keir Starmer's winter fuel U-turn
Pensioners could be forced to wait 12 months for Keir Starmer’s winter fuel U-turn
The battle to succeed Sir Keir Starmer has already started
The battle to succeed Sir Keir Starmer has already started
MPs condemn 'bizarre' state pension rule as 500,000 get no triple lock increase
MPs condemn ‘bizarre’ state pension rule as 500,000 get no triple lock increase
Kemi Badenoch slams 'desperate' Keir Starmer for 'shafting country' on winter fuel U-turn
Kemi Badenoch slams ‘desperate’ Keir Starmer for ‘shafting country’ on winter fuel U-turn
Keir Starmer's EU sellout perfectly skewered in seven-word slapdown of PM
Keir Starmer’s EU sellout perfectly skewered in seven-word slapdown of PM
Keir Starmer has no backbone and pensioners shoul be worried about his winter fuel U-turn
Keir Starmer has no backbone and pensioners shoul be worried about his winter fuel U-turn
Pensioners want clarity on Keir Starmer's 'screeching' winter fuel payment U-turn
Pensioners want clarity on Keir Starmer’s ‘screeching’ winter fuel payment U-turn
Keir Starmer's winter fuel 'panic' exposed as PM warned 'voters won't buy it'
Keir Starmer’s winter fuel ‘panic’ exposed as PM warned ‘voters won’t buy it’

Keir Starmer Departs Downing Street for PMQs in London

The PM announced his U-turn at PMQs this week (Image: Getty)

When asked by host Fiona Bruce about whether she would advocate getting rid of the triple lock, the journalist replied: “I think we need to have a national conversation,” as other panelists could be heard saying “yes!”

Fellow guest Zanny Minton Beddoes went one step further.

She said: “I’ll go further and say that triple lock should go. In an aging society, we cannot continue to maintain these promises to the older generation, leaving a huge burden on younger generations.

“I think we need to have an honest discussion about that and I think the triple lock should go.”

The triple lock was introduced in 2012 and ensures that the state pension goes up each year by the highest of three metrics: 2.5%, inflation, or earnings growth.

Members Of The UNITE Trade Union Protest Over The Scrapping Of Winter Fuel Payments

The original policy decision was described as a “car crash” by one guest (Image: Getty)

Labour MP Nick Thomas-Symonds attempted to defend the government’s decision to ease their stance on the winter fuel payment, which was described by other panellists as a “car crash policy”, whilst maintaining the government’s support of the measure.

The Paymaster General insisted that the government were forced to means test the once universal benefit as a result of the country’s economic situation but claimed that recent growth statistics laid behind the decision to reverse the controversial measure, rather than Labour embarrassing local election performance.

He said: “I don’t think that anyone thinks that it is a good use of public money to be paying the winter fuel payment to millionaires, I think it is right to means test it.

“After the local elections, the prime minister said that ‘I get it’ and that is why we will be increasing the number of pensioners who are entitled to it.”

LEAVE A RESPONSE

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *